WT/DS138/R
Complaint by European
Communities
Report of the Panel
$B!cL\
$B#1!%(B$B@h7hLdBj(B
$B#2!%(B$BG/r5Z$S#1#9!%#4>r@09g@-(B
$B0F7o(B
$B%$%.%j%9@=E49]@=IJ$K78$kAj;&4X@GA
$B?=N)9q(B
$B#E#C(B(European
Communities)
$BHo?=N)9q(B
$BJF9q(B
$B;22CBh;09q(B
$B%V%i%8%k!"%a%-%7%3(B
$B%Q%M%j%9%H(B
Mr. Ole Lundby
Mr. Paul O$B!G(BConnor
Mr. Arie Reich
$B
$BJd=u6b6(Dj!JJd=u6b$*$h$SAj;&A
$B7P0^(B
$B#1#9#9#8G/!!#67n#1#2F|!!6(5DMW@A(B
$B#1#9#9#9G/!!#17n#1#4F|!!%Q%M%k@_CVMW@A(B
$B#1#9#9#9G/!!#27n#1#7F|!!%Q%M%k@_CV(B
$B#1#9#9#9G/#1#27n#2#3F|!!%Q%M%kJs9p(B
$B#2#0#0#0G/!!#57n#1#0F|!!>e5i0Q0w2qJs9p(B
$B#2#0#0#0G/!!#67n!!#7F|!!%Q%M%kJs9p!&>e5i0Q0w2qJs9p:NBr(B
$B"(>e5i0Q0w2q7hDj$K$D$$$F$O!"(B$B>e5i0Q0w2q7hDjJ,@O(B$B$r;29M$K$7$F$/$@$5$$!#(B
$B#1!%7P0^(B
|
$B;v9`(B |
|
|
$B#1#9#9#2G/#57n#8F|(B |
$BAj;&4X@GD4::3+;O(B $B;:IJ!'%$%.%j%9@=(Bhot-rolled lead and bismuth carbon steel |
|
$B#1#9#9#3G/#17n#2#7F|(B |
$B>&L3>J!"Jd=u6bN(7hDj(B $BJd=u6bN(!'(B12.69% $BA |
|
$B#1#9#9#3G/#37n#2#2F|(B |
$BAj;&4X@GIj2](B |
|
$B#1#9#9#4G/#47n#1#5F|(B |
$BBh#12sG/ |
|
$B#1#9#9#5G/#37n#2#1F|(B |
$B#U#E#S!"#B#S#P#l#c$NA43[=P;q;R2q $B#U#E#S!"(BBritish Steel Engineering Steels($B#B#S#E#S(B)$B$H2~L>(B |
|
$B#1#9#9#5G/#47n#1#5F|(B $B!A#1#9#9#6G/#1#17n#1#4F|(B |
$BBh#22sG/ $BJd=u6bN(!'(B1.69% $BA |
|
$B#1#9#9#6G/#47n#2#5F|(B $B!A#1#9#9#7G/#1#07n#1#4F|(B |
$BBh#32sG/ $B!#9#9#5G/#17n#1F|!A#1#9#9#5G/#37n#2#0F|(B $BJd=u6bN(!'(B2.40% $BA $B!#9#9#5G/#37n#2#1F|!A#1#9#9#5G/#1#27n#3#1F|(B $BJd=u6bN(!'(B7.35% $BA |
|
$B#1#9#9#7G/#47n#2#9F|(B $B!A#1#9#9#8G/#47n#1#5F|(B |
$BBh#42sG/ $BJd=u6bN(!'(B5.28% $BA |
|
$B#1#9#9#8G/#47n#2#4F|(B |
$BBh#52sG/ |
|
$B#1#9#9#9G/#47n#3#0F|(B |
$BBh#62sG/ |
$B"(Aj;&A
$B"(K\7o?3::$NBP>]$H$J$C$?$N$O!"Bh#22s$+$iBh#42s$NG/
$B"(;29M(B
$B%Q%M%k7hDj$NJ,@O(B
r$NBP>]HO0O(B>$B#1!%@h7hLdBj(B(Preliminary
Issues)
$BK5D0?M$N;22C(B(Participation of observers)
$B!!JF9q$O!"%Q%M%k$HEv;v9q$H$N2q9g$KK5D0?M$r;22C$5$;$k$3$H$r5a$a$F$$$?!#(B
$B!!%Q%M%k$O!"(6.2)$B!#K5D0?M$N;22C$O2q9g$NHs8x3+$rDj$a$?J6Ah2r7hN;2r!J#D#S#U!KImB0=q#3$N8!F$
$B%"%_%+%9!&%-%e%j%((B(Amicus curiae brief)
$B!!#1#9#9#9G/#77n#1#9F|!"%Q%M%k$O#A#I#S#I(B(American Iron and Steel Industry)$B$+$i0U8+=q$r
$B!!%Q%M%k$O!"%Q%M%k$,$3$&$7$?=qLL$r8!F$$9$k:[NL$rM-$9$k$3$H$rG'$a$D$D!"$3$N=qLL$,N>Ev;v9q$NBh#22s=qLL(B(rebuttal submissions)$BDs=P$HBh#22s%Q%M%k2q9g$N8e$KDs=P$5$l!"N>Ev;v9q$,$3$N=qLL$K%3%a%s%H$9$k5!2q$,$J$+$C$?$H$$$&$3$H$r9MN8$7$F!"$3$N0U8+=q$r8!F$$7$J$$$H=R$Y$?(B(6.3)$B!#(B
$B>pJs$NMW@A(B(Request for information)
$B!!#E#C$O!"%Q%M%k$,JF9q$K$"$k>pJs$NDs6!$rMW@A$9$k$h$&5a$a$F$$$?!#JF9q$O!"HkL)>pJs$G$"$jDs6!$G$-$J$$$H$3$?$($F$$$?!#(B
$B!!%Q%M%k$O!"#D#S#U#1#3>r$K$h$j%Q%M%k$,>pJs$rMW@A$9$k9-HO$J8"Mx$rM-$7$F$$$k$3$H$rG'$a$J$,$i!"K\7o2r7h$N$?$a$K#E#C$NMW@A$7$F$$$k>pJs$O9MN8$9$kI,MW$,$J$$$H$7$F!"#E#C$N5a$a$rB`$1$?(B(6.6-6.7)$B!#(B
$B?3::4p=`(B(Standard of review)
$B!!K\7o%Q%M%k?3::$K$*$1$k?3::4p=`$,%"%s%A%@%s%T%s%06(Dj#1#7!%#6>r(B(ii)$B$K5,Dj$5$l$k?3::4p=`$J$N$+!JJF9q$N
$B!!%Q%M%k$Or$N?3::4p=`$rMQ$$$k$H$7$?!#-!JF9q$,:,5r$H$7$F$$$k#1#9#9#4G/$N%"%s%A%@%s%T%s%06(DjKt$OJd=u6b6(DjBh#5It$K4p$E$/J6Ah2r7h$K4X$9$k@k8@(B(Declaration on Dispute Settlement Pursuant to the Agreement on
Implementation of Article VI of the GATT 1994 or Part V of the Agreement on
Subsidies and Countervailing Measures)$B$O!"%"%s%A%@%s%T%s%06(Dj#1#7!%#6>r$N?3::4p=`$rAj;&4X@G$K4X$9$kJ6Ah$GMQ$$$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$$H$ODj$a$F$$$J$$$7!"$^$?94B+NO$N$"$k7hDj(B(decision)$B$G$O$J$/@k8@$G$"$k$3$H$K$bN10U$7$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$(B(6.17)$B!"-"Jd=u6b6(Dj#3#0>r$K$h$l$P!"!VJLCJ$NDj$a$,$"$k>l9g!W$r=|$$$F#D#S#U$N5,Dj$,=`MQ$5$l$J$/$F$O$J$i$:!"$^$??3::4p=`$K$D$$$FJd=u6b$OJLCJ$NDj$a$r$7$F$$$J$$(B(6.18)$B!#(B
$B#2!%#1#9#9#5G/!"#1#9#9#6G/!"#1#9#9#7G/$NG/r5Z$S#1#9!%#4>r@09g@-(B(Were the
Countervailing Duties Imposed as a Result of the 1995, 1996 and 1997
Administrative Reviews Consistent with Articles 10 and 19.4 of the SCM
Agreement)
$BJd=u6b6(Dj#1#0>r$H$N@09g@-(B(The EC Article 10 claim)
$B!!#E#C$O!"JF9q$OJd=u6b6(Dj#1#9>r$d#1#9#9#4G/$N#G#A#T#T#6!%#3>r$K0cH?$7$FAj;&4X@G$rIj2]$7$F$*$j!"$7$?$,$C$FJd=u6b6(Dj#1#0>r$K0cH?$7$?$H
$B!!%Q%M%k$Or!"#1#9!%#4>r!"#2#1!%#2>r!"#1#9#9#4G/$N#G#A#T#T#6!%#3>r$NMW7o$rK~$?$5$:$KAj;&4X@G$rIj2]$7$F$*$j!"$7$?$,$C$FJd=u6b6(Dj#1#0>r$K0cH?$7$?$HG'$a$?!#-!Jd=u6b6(Dj#1#9!%#1>r!"#1#9!%#4>r!"#2#1!%#2>r!"#1#9#9#4G/$N#G#A#T#T#6!%#3>r$+$i!"Aj;&2DG=$JJd=u6b$,$J$$$H$-$K$OAj;&4X@G$rIj2]$7$F$O$J$i$:(B(no countervailing
duty may be imposed absent (countervailable)
subsidization)$B!"$3$l$OJd=u6b6(Dj#1#0>rCm#1$K5,Dj$5$l$k(B$BJd=u6b$rAj;&$9$k$H$$$&Aj;&4X@G$NL\E*$K$b@09gE*$G$"$k(B(6.49-6.57)$B!"-"Jd=u6b6(Dj#1!%#1>r$K$h$l$P!"Jd=u6b$NB8:_$,G'$a$i$l$k$?$a$K$O!"@/I\$^$?$O8xE*5!4X$N;q6bLL$G$N9W8%$K$h$jMx1W$,$b$?$i$5$l$F$$$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$$,!"Mx1W$,$"$k$+H]$+$O!"K!?M!"<+A3?M!"$^$?$OCDBN$G$"$kJd=u6b$N
$BJd=u6b6(Dj#1#9!%#4>r$H$N@09g@-(B(The EC Article 19.4 claim)
$B!!#E#C$O!"G/r0cH?$b
$B%Q%M%k$N(B$B7kO@5Z$S4+9p(B
$B0J>e$h$j!"%Q%M%k$O!"#1#9#9#4G/$+$i#1#9#9#6G/$NAj;&4X@GIj2]!J#1#9#9#5G/$+$i#1#9#9#7G/$NG/r$K0cH?$7$?$H7kO@$9$k!#(B
$B%Q%M%k$O!"#D#S#U#3!%#8>r$K$h$j!"#E#C$N6(Dj>e$NMx1W$,L58z2=$^$?$O?/32$5$l$F$$$k$H7kO@$9$k!#(B
$B%Q%M%k$O!"#D#S#U#1#9!%#1>r$K4p$E$-!"JF9q$,Jd=u6b6(Dj$K@09g$9$k$h$&A
$B$J$*!"#E#C$O%Q%M%k$KBP$7$F!"Aj;&4X@GK!$r2~@5$7;T>l2A3J$G$NL11D2=$K$h$jJd=u6b$,>CLG$9$k$3$H$rL@3N$K$9$k$h$&JF9q$KDs0F$9$k$3$H$r5a$a$F$$$?!#$3$l$KBP$7%Q%M%k$O!"#E#C$OK\7o$N$h$&$J0cH?A
© 2003 Yuka Fukunaga All Rights Reserved