WT/DS138/AB/R

$B!!>e5i0Q0w2q$O!"(the American Iron and Steel Institute; the Specialty Steel Industry of North America)$B$+$iDs=P$5$l$?%"%_%+%9!&%-%e%j%($r8!F$$9$kI,MW$O$J$$$H=R$Y$?!#-!#D#S#U!JJ6Ah2r7hN;2r!K$d>e5i0Q0w2q:n6Hr$K$h$l$P>e5i0Q0w2q$O#D#S#U$J$I$KH?$7$J$$6(Dj$N5,Dj$KH?$7$J$$8B$j>e5i0Q0w2q$O4XO"$,$"$jM-1W$J>pJs$r(we are of the opinion that as long as we act consistently with the provisions of the DSU and the covered agreements, we have the legal authority to decide whether or not to accept and consider any information that we believe is pertinent and useful in appeal)(39)$B!"-"$H$O$$$(!"2CLA9q$G$J$$8D?M$dCDBN$O!">e5i0Q0w2q$K0U8+=q$rDs=P$9$k$J$I$NK!E*(B$B8"Mx(B$B$rM-$;$:(B(have no legal right)$B!">e5i0Q0w2q$O$3$l$i$N0U8+=q$r8!F$$9$k(B$B5AL3(B$B$rM-$5$J$$(B(have no legal duty)(41)$B!#(B

$B#2!%?3::4p=`(B(Standard of Review)

$B!!>e5i0Q0w2q$O!"r$N?3::4p=`$,E,MQ$5$l$k$H$7$?%Q%M%k$NH=CG$r;Y;}$7$?!#-!JF9q$,%"%s%A%@%s%T%s%06(Dj#1#7!%#6>r$N?3::4p=`$,E,MQ$5$l$k$H(does not impose an obligation)$B!"$^$?J88@$b4+9pE*$G(B(in hortatory language)$B!"$^$?6qBNE*$J9T0Y$d?3::4p=`$r5,Dj$7$F$$$k$o$1$G$b$J$$(B(49)$B!"-"#1#9#9#4G/$N4X@G5Z$SKG0W$K4X$9$k0lHL6(DjBh#6>r$Nr#6$N8!F$$K4X$9$k7hDj(B(Decision on Review of Article 17.6 of the Agreement on Implementation of Article VI of the GATT 1994)$B$O!"%"%s%A%@%s%T%s%06(Dj#1#7!%#6>r$N0lHLE*E,MQ$N2DH]$r8!F$$9$k$H5,Dj$7!"8=CJ3,$G$O$=$N$h$&$J8!F$$O9T$o$l$F$$$J$$$3$H$+$i!"Jd=u6b6(DjBh#5It$K4X$9$kK\7oJ6Ah$K$O#D#S#U#1#1>r$N?3::4p=`$,E,MQ$5$l$k(B(50)$B!#(B

$B#3!%Jd=u6b6(Dj#2#1>r5Z$S#1!%#1>r(B(b)(Articles 21 and 1.1(b) of the SCM Agreement)

$B!!>e5i0Q0w2q$O!"r5Z$S#1#9!%#4>r$r:,5r$H$7$F7kO@$rF3$$$F$$$k$,!"K\7o$GLdBj$H$J$C$F$$$k$N$OG/r5Z$S#1#9!%#4>r$OM-1W$JJ8L.$G$O$"$k$b$N$N!":,5r$H$9$Y$-$O%l%S%e!<$K4X$9$k#2#1>r$G$"$k(B(53)$B!"-"(BCanada – Aircraft$B>e5i0Q0w2qJs9p5Z$SJd=u6b6(Dj#1#4>r$h$j!"%Q%M%k$NG'Dj$7$?$h$&$K!"Jd=u6b6(Dj#1!%#1>r(B(b)$B$NMx1W$NM-L5$O<+A3?M$^$?$OK!?M$G$"$kJd=u6b$r(57-58)$B!"-#Jd=u6b6(Dj#1!%#1>r!"#1#4>r!"#2#7!%#1#3>r$O!";q6bLL$G$N9W8%$dMx1W$N$"$C$?(B$B;~4|(B(the time at which the $B!H(Bfinancial contribution$B!I(B and/or the $B!H(Bbenefit$B!I(B must be shown to exist)$B$K$D$$$F2?$b5,Dj$7$F$$$J$$$,!"Jd=u6b6(Dj#2#1!%#1>r5Z$S#2#1!%#2>r$K$h$l$P!"%l%S%e!<$K$*$$$FD4::Ev6I$OAj;&4X@GIj2]$r7QB3$9$kI,MW@-$,$"$k$+(B(whether there is a continuing need for the application of countervailing duties)$B$rG'Dj$7$J$/$F$O$J$i$:!">&L3>J$O#U#E#S$d#B#S#p#l#c!?#B#S#E#S$KMx1W$,M?$($i$l$F$$$k$+H]$+$rG/(60-62)$B!"-$$?$@$7!"%Q%M%k$O%l%S%e!<$K$*$$$F$bI,$:Mx1W$NB8:_$r>ZL@$7$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$$H<(:6$7$F$$$k$,!"Jd=u6b6(Dj>e$N$9$Y$F$N>r7o$rD4::$7$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$%*%j%8%J%kD4::$H$O0[$J$j!"G/l9g$K$OD4::$KCM$9$kLdBj$r8!F$$9$l$P$h$$(B(In an administrative review, $B!D(B the investigating authority must address those issues which have been raised before it by the interested parties or, in the case of an investigation conducted on its own initiatives, those issues which warranted the examination)(63)$B!"-%JF9q$O%Q%M%k$,?75,$N8+D>$7(B(de novo review)$B$r9T$C$?$He5i0Q0w2q2q9g$K$*$$$F!"$3$3$GLdBj$H$J$C$F$$$k%Q%M%kG'Dj$,(B$B;v$BG'Dj(B(factual findings)$B$G$"$j!"$3$N;veAJ$7$F$$$J$$(B(does not challenge)$B$HG'$a$F$*$j(B(acknowledged)$B!"$3$N(64-66)$B!"-&%Q%M%k$N;v(68)$B!"-'JF9q$O!">&L3>J$,Mx1W$NB8:_$r>ZL@$9$Y$-$G$"$C$?$HG'Dj$7$?$N$_$GEv;v9q4V$NJ6Ah$O2r7h$5$l$F$*$j!"%Q%M%k$,Mx1W$,M?$($i$l$F$$$J$$$H$^$G7kO@$7$?$3$H$O%Q%M%k$N%^%s%G!<%H$r1[$($F$$$k$H (72-74)$B!#(B

$B>e5i0Q0w2q$N(B$B7kO@5Z$S4+9p(B

$B!!0J>e$h$j!">e5i0Q0w2q$O

(a) $B%Q%M%k$,Jd=u6b6(DjBh#5It$K4X$9$kJ6Ah$K#D#S#U#1#1>r$N?3::4p=`$rE,MQ$7$?$N$OBEEv$G$"$C$?!#(B

(b) $BK\7o$K$*$$$F!">&L3>J$O#1#9#9#5G/$+$i#1#9#9#7G/$NG/

(c) $B#B#S#C$X$N;q6bLL$G$N9W8%$K$h$C$F#U#E#S$d#B#S#p#l#c!?#B#S#E#S$KMx1W$OM?$($i$l$F$$$J$$$H$7$?%Q%M%k$NG'Dj$r;Y;}$9$k!#(B

$B!!>e5i0Q0w2q$O!"#D#S#B!JJ6Ah2r7h5!4X!K$,JF9q$KBP$7$FJd=u6b6(Dj$K0cH?$7$F$$$k$HG'Dj$5$l$?A