WT/DS165/R

17 July 2000

United States – Import Measures on Certain Products From the European Communities

    Complaint by the European Communities

Report of the panel

 

$B!cL\

$B0F7o(B

$B?=N)9q(B

$BHo?=N)9q(B

$B

$B;22CBh;09q(B

$B7P0^(B

$B;v

$B#1!%(B$B7P0^(B

$B#2!%(B$BBP>]A

$B%Q%M%k7hDj$NJ,@O(B

$B#1!%(B$B#D#S#U#2#3>r$HK\7oA

$B#2!%(B$B#D#S#U#2#3!%#1>rJB$S$K#D#S#U#2#3!%#2>r!J#c!K!"#3!%#7>r!"#2#2!%#6>r$K4X$9$k?=N)(B

$B#3!%(B$B#D#S#U#2#3!%#1>rJB$S$K#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r!"#2#3!%#2>r!J#a!K$K4X$9$k?=N)(B

$B#4!%(B$B$=$NB>(B

$B%Q%M%k$N7kO@5Z$S4+9p(B

 

$B0F7o(B

$B#E#C$+$i$NFCDjIJL\$K78$kM"F~A

 

*$B?=N)9q(B

$B#E#C(B(European Communities)

 

*$BHo?=N)9q(B

$BJF9q(B

 

*$B

$B#D#S#U!JJ6Ah2r7h$K78$k5,B'5Z$S

 

*$B;22CBh;09q(B

$B%I%_%K%+!"%;%s%H%k%7%"!"%(%/%"%I%k!"%$%s%I!"%8%c%^%$%+!"F|K\(B

 

*$B7P0^(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/!!#37n!!#4F|!!6(5DMW@A(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/!!#57n#1#1F|!!%Q%M%k@_CVMW@A(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/!!#67n#1#6F|!!%Q%M%k@_CV(B

$B#2#0#0#0G/!!#77n#1#7F|!!%Q%M%kJs9p(B

$B#2#0#0#0G/#1#27n#1#1F|!!>e5i0Q0w2qJs9p(B

$B#2#0#0#1G/!!#17n#1#0F|!!%Q%M%kJs9p!&>e5i0Q0w2qJs9p:NBr(B

$B"(>e5i0Q0w2q7hDj$K$D$$$F$O!"(B$B>e5i0Q0w2q7hDjJ,@O(B$B$r;29M$K$7$F$/$@$5$$!#(B

 

*$B;v

$B#1!%7P0^(B

$B7nF|(B

$B;v9`(B

$B#1#9#9#7G/#97n#2#5F|(B

EC-Bananas III$B>e5i0QJs9p:NBr!#(B

$B#1#9#9#7G/#1#07n#1#6F|(B

$B#D#S#B(B$B!JJ6Ah2r7h5!4X!K2q9g$K$F#E#C$O>e5->e5i0QJs9p$r

$B#1#9#9#8G/#17n#7F|(B

$BCg:[?M$K$h$j!">e5i0QJs9p

$B#1#9#9#8G/#77n#2#0F|(B

$B#E#U!"%P%J%J;T>l$K4X$9$k#E#E#C5,B'(BNo.404/93$B$r=$@5$9$k#E#C5,B'(BNo.1637/98$B:NBr(B

$B#1#9#9#8G/#1#07n#2#8F|(B

$B#E#U!"%P%J%JM"F~$K4X$9$k#E#E#C5,B'(BNo.404/93$B$rNo.2362/98$B:NBr(B

$B#1#9#9#8G/#87n#1#8F|(B

EC-Bananas III$B?=N)9q$O!"#E#C$N?7%P%J%JM"F~BN@)Ds0F$K$D$$$F!"O"BS$7$F(B(jointly and severally)$B6(5D$rMW@A(B

$B#1#9#9#8G/#97n#8F|(B

EC-Bananas III$B?=N)9q$O!"#D#S#B5DD9$KBP$7!"#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r$K4p$E$/%Q%M%k@_CV$r5a$a$k!J@_CV$5$l$:!K(B

$B"(;vA06(5D$,#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r$K4p$E$/%Q%M%k@_CV$N>r7o$G$"$k$+H]$+$GEv;v9q4V$KAh$$$,$"$C$?!#!JJF9q$J$I$O>r7o$G$J$$!"#E#C$O>r7o$G$"$k!"$H

$B#1#9#9#9G/#17n#1#2F|(B

$B#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r$K4p$E$/%Q%M%k$,@_CV!J%(%/%"%I%k?=N)$N;v9`$H!"#E#C?=N)$N;v9`$K4X$9$k$b$N!K(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#17n#1#4F|(B

$BJF9q$O!"#D#S#U#2#2!%#2>r$K4p$E$-!"#E#C$*$h$S$=$N2CLA9q$KBP$9$k>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$N>5G'$r#D#S#B$K5a$a$k(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#17n#2#9F|(B

$B#E#C$O!"#D#S#U#2#2!%#6>r$K4p$E$-!"JF9q$NDs0F$7$?>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$N5,LO$KH?BP$rI=L@(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#17n#2#5!"#2#8!"#2#9F|!"#27n#1F|(B

$B#D#S#B$O!">y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$N5,LO$K$D$$$F!"#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r%Q%M%k$NCg:[$K$h$j7hDj$9$k$3$H$K9g0U(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#27n#1#8F|(B

$BJF9q$O!"#D#S#U#2#2!%#7>r$K4p$E$-!"#E#C$*$h$S$=$N2CLA9q$KBP$9$k>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$N>5G'$r#D#S#B$K5a$a$k(B

$BJF9q$O$^$?!"#D#S#U#2#2!%#6>r$K$h$l$PCg:[?M$N7hDj$O#1#9#9#9G/#37n#2F|$^$G$K=P$5$l$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!"$H=R$Y$k(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#37n#2F|(B

$BCg:[?M$O!"Ev;v9q$KDI2CE*>pJs$NDs6!$r5a$a!"Ev3:>pJs$,F@$i$l

$B#1#9#9#9G/#37n#3F|(B

$BJF9q$O!"#1#9#9#9G/#37n#3F|$^$G$KCg:[?M$N7hDj$,=P$5$l$J$+$C$?$3$H$rM}M3$H$7$F!"#E#C$+$i$NFCDjIJL\$NM"F~$K$D$$$FA

$B#1#9#9#9G/#37n#4F|(B

$B#E#C$O!"JF9q$H$N6(5DMW@A!J#1#9#9#9G/#67n#1#6F|K\7o%Q%M%k@_CV$K$$$?$k!K(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#47n#6F|(B

$B>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$NDxEY$K4X$9$k#D#S#U#2#2!%#6>rCg:[?M$N7hDj$H!"#E#C$N?7%P%J%JM"F~BN@)Ds0F$,0MA3$H$7$F#1#9#9#4G/#G#A#T#T$*$h$S#G#A#T#S$K0cH?$7$F$$$k$H$N#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r%Q%M%kJs9p$,=P$5$l$k(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#47n#7F|(B

$BJF9q$O!">e5-Cg:[?M$N7hDj$K4p$E$->y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$r9T$&>5G'$r#D#S#B$K5a$a$k(B

$B#1#9#9#9G/#47n#1#9F|(B

$B#D#S#B$O!"JF9q$N#D#S#U#2#2!%#7>rMW@A$K4p$E$-!"JF9q$,#E#C$*$h$S$=$N2CLA9q$KBP$9$k>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3$rDd;_$9$k$3$H$r>5G'(B

 

$B#2!%BP>]A

$B!!JF9q$G$ODL>o!"F~4I;~$K$O4X@G$N8+9~$_3[$N$_$r;YJ'$$!"$=$NB>$N@G3[$dNA6b$O@:;;$N:]$K;YJ'$o$l$k!#$^$?!"(Bcontinuous bond$B$b$7$/$O(Bsingle transaction bond$B!J#S#T#B!K$H$$$&MBBw6b$NMBBw$K$h$j!"@:;;A0$KJ]@GCO0h$+$i$NHB=P$,2DG=$H$J$k$,!"#9#0!s0J>e$NM"F~$K$D$$$F!"(Bcontinuous bond$B$,MxMQ$5$l$F$$$?!#(B

$B!!#1#9#9#9G/#37n#3F|!"JF9q$O!"Cg:[?M$N:G=*7hDj$,=P$5$l$kA0$K!"#E#C$+$i$NFCDjIJL\$KBP$7#1#0#0%Q!<%;%s%H$N=>2A4X@G$rIU2C$9$k8"Mx$r3NJ]$9$k(B(preserve its right to impose 100 percent duties as of March 3)$B$?$a!"@G4XEv6I$K@:;;$NJ]N1$r5a$a$?(B(withholding liquidation)$B!#JF9q@G4X$O!"#E#C$+$i$NFCDjIJL\$KBP$7!"86B'$H$7$F#S#T#B(B(Single Transaction Bond)$B$r!"Nc30$H$7$FA0G/$+$iMQ$$$i$l$F$$$k(Bcontinuous bond$B>e>h$;$r5a$a$?!Jcontinuous bond$B$N>e>h$;$H$$$&7A$r$H$C$?!K!##1#9#9#9G/#47n#1#9F|$K#D#S#B$N>5G'$,$($i$l$?8e!"JF9q$O!"#37n#3F|$NA]$H$J$C$F$$$?IJL\$N0lIt$K$D$$$F!"#1#0#0!s$N=>2A4X@GIj2]$r7hDj$7$?!#(B

$B!!$J$*!"E}7W$K$h$k$H!"#37n#3F|$NA]$H$J$C$?IJL\$O!"#1#9#9#9G/#37n0J9_7QB3$7$FM"F~NL$O8:>/$7$?!#0lJ}!"#37n#3F|$NA]$G$O$"$k$,#47n#1#9F|$NA]$H$J$i$J$+$C$?IJL\$O!"#1#9#9#9G/#4!"#57n$K$OM"F~NL$,8:>/$7$?$,!"#1#9#9#9G/#67n0J9_$O0JA0$N?e=`$K2sI|$7$?!#(B

 

 

$B%Q%M%k7hDj$NJ,@O(B

r$NBP>]HO0O(B>$B%Q%M%k$O!"%Q%M%k$NIUBw;v9`$O#37n#3F|$NA$N<~JU;v>p$r9MN8$9$kI,MW$,$"$k$H=R$Y$?>e$G!"

 

$B#1!%#D#S#U#2#3>r$N0U5A$HK\7oA

$B!!%Q%M%k$O!"#D#S#U#2#3>r$N0U5A$K$D$$$F!"(BUS-Section 301$B%Q%M%k7hDj$K8@5Z$7$D$D!"(threaten the stability and predictability of the multilateral trade system)$B0lJ}E*Ar$K$h$C$F6X;_$5$l$F$$$k$H2r$9$Y$-$G$"$k!"-"#D#S#U#2#3!%#2>r$NNs5s$9$k6KC<$JNc$NB>$K$b#D#S#U#2#3!%#1>r$K0cH?$9$k0lJ}E*A

$B!!%Q%M%k$O!"r$NE,MQBP>]$H$J$k$3$H$rG'$a$?!#-!#D#S#U#2#3>r$NE,MQBP>]$H$J$k$N$O!"#W#T#O0cH?$N!V@'@5$r5a$a$k!W(B($B!H(Bseeking the redress of$B!I(B a WTO violation)$BAu67$r5_:Q(B(remedying)$B$9$k$?$a0cH?9q$K2?$i$+$NBP1~$r$7$h$&(B(reaction)$B$H;n$_$k(B(effort)$BA&K!#3#0#1>r$NOHAH$_$GH/F0$5$l$?$3$H!"JF9q@G4X$+$i3FCO6h$N@G4X$X$N3P=q!"#U#S#T#R$N%W%l%9!&%+%s%U%!%l%s%9$G$N

 

$B#2!%#D#S#U#2#3!%#1>rJB$S$K#D#S#U#2#3!%#2>r!J#c!K!"#3!%#7>r!"#2#2!%#6>r$K4X$9$k?=N)(B

$B!!%Q%M%k$O$^$:!"#D#S#U#2#3!%#2>r!J#c!K!"#3!%#7>r!"#2#2!%#6>r$K$h$l$P!"#D#S#B$N>5G'$r$($kA0$K#W#T#O>e$N>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3$rDd;_$9$k$3$H$OL@<(E*$K6X;_$5$l$F$$$k!"$H=R$Y$?!#$5$i$K!"#1#9#9#9G/#37n#3F|$N;~E@$G$O!">y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$K4X$9$k#D#S#B$N>5G'$,$J$+$C$?$3$H$r3NG'$7$?!#(B

$B%Q%M%k$Oy5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$KAjEv$9$k$+$K$D$$$F!"EEC-Measures on Animal Feed  Proteins$B!"(BEEC-Minimum Import Price$B!"(BUS-Section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930$B3F#G#A#T#T%Q%M%k7hDj$G$b(B$B;XE&$5$l$?$h$&$K!"MBBw6b$N#W#T#O@09g@-$O!"MBBw6b$,J]>Z$7$h$&$H$9$k8"MxKt$O5AL3$K>H$i$7$F?3::$9$Y$-$G$"$k(B(should be assessed together with the principal rights/obligations they aim to guarantee)$B!"-"#37n#3F|$NAe>h$;$5$l$?MBBw6b$rMBBw$;$M$P$J$i$:!"$3$NAr$*$h$S#2>r$K0cH?$7$F$$$k!J"(!K!"-#(BEEC-Minimum Import Price$B#G#A#T#T%Q%M%k7hDj$G$b=R$Y$i$l$F$$$k$h$&$K!">e>h$;$5$l$?MBBw6b$rMBBw$9$k$?$a$K;YJ'$o$l$?HqMQ$O!"JF9q$K;YJ'$o$l$k$b$N$G$J$$$H$7$F$b#G#A#T#T#2!%#1>r!J#b!K$G6X;_$5$l$F$$$k!VAE@GKt$O2]D'6b(B(other duties and charges)$B!W$KAjEv$9$k!"-$$?$@$7!">e>h$;$5$l$?MBBw6b$rMBBw$9$k$?$a$K;YJ'$o$l$?HqMQ$,#G#A#T#T#8>r$N!VDs6!$5$l$?LrL3$N35;;$NHqMQ(B(approximate cost of services rendered)$B!W$KAjEv$9$k$H$$$&#E#C$Nr!J#c!K!"#3!%#7>r!"#2#2!%#6>rE,MQ$K78$k!V>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_!W$K0l1~(B(prima facie)$BAjEv$9$k$H7kO@$9$k!#(B

$B!!%Q%M%k$O!"$lB`$1$?!#-!JF9q$O!"#37n#3F|$NA2A6(Dj!J#1#9#9#4G/$N#G#A#T#T#7>r$Nr$K$h$C$FL@<(E*$K5v$5$l$F$$$k$H2A6(Dj$OM"F~;:IJ$N4X@GI>2A$NIT0BDj$5$K4X$7$FJ]>Z$rM?$($k$b$N$G$"$j(B(guarantee system when there is uncertainty regarding the customs value of the imported products)$B!"4X@GI>2A$G$O$J$/4X@G5AL3$N%l%Y%k$=$N$b$N(B(the level of tariff obligations as such)$B$KAh$$$,$"$kK\7o$K$O4X78$,$J$$!"-"JF9q$O!"#37n#3F|$NA5G'$K$h$j4X@G%l%Y%k$,JQ$o$k$H$$$&%j%9%/(B(variation in tariff level constituted a $B!F(Brisk$B!G(B)$B$KBP1~$9$k$b$N$G$"$k$H5G'$9$k>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$NL\E*$O!"#W#T#O6(Dj0cH?$K$h$C$F<:$o$l$?Mx1W$KBP$9$k6bA,E*Jd=~$G$O$J$/(B(not to obtain monetary compensation for an amount equivalent to the lost trade)$B!"#W#T#O6(Dj0cH?$K$h$C$F1F6A$r(to restrict trade to an extent equivalent to the trade affected by the incompatible measure)$B$K$h$j6(Dj0cH?$rHH$7$?9q$K@'@5A(in order to induce compliance of that Member)$B!"#D#S#B$,AL5ZE*$K>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$r>5G'$9$k(B($B!F(Bretroactive$B!G(B permission)$B$3$H$O9M$($i$l$J$$$7!"$^$?$=$b$=$bJF9q$O#D#S#B$K$=$N$h$&$JAL5ZE*>5G'$rM?$($k$3$H$r5a$a$F$b$$$J$$!#(B

$B!!0J>e$h$j%Q%M%k$O!"JF9q$N#37n#3F|$NA5G'$,$J$$$K$b$+$+$o$i$:#E#C$KBP$7$F>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3$rDd;_$7$F$*$j!J#G#A#T#T#1!"#2!%#1!J#a!K!"#2!%#1!J#b!K>r0cH?!K!"$7$?$,$C$FJF9q$O#D#S#U#2#3!%#2>r!J#c!K!"#3!%#7>r!"#2#2!%#6>r$K0cH?$7!"$=$l$K$h$j#D#S#U#2#3!%#1>r$K$b0cH?$7$?!#$H7kO@$7$?!#(B

 

$B"(J,@O

$B#37n#3F|$NAr$H$$$&$h$j#G#A#T#T#1#1>r$K0cH?$7$F$$$k$H2r$9$Y$-!"$H$$$&%Q%M%j%9%H$N8DJL0U8+$,IU$5$l$?!#(B

 

$B#3!%#D#S#U#2#3!%#1>rJB$S$K#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r!"#2#3!%#2>r!J#a!K$K4X$9$k?=N)(B

$B!!#E#C$O!"#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r$Nr$K0cH?$9$k$H

$B!!%Q%M%k$O#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r$N0UL#$K$D$$$F!"rBh#1J8$O!"#D#S#U#2#3!%#2>r!J#a!K$KAjEv$7!"%Q%M%k!?>e5i0Q0w2qJs9p$N(implementing measure)$B$N#W#T#O6(Dj@09g@-$K4X$9$k7hDj$O#W#T#OJ6Ah=hM}(can only be made through the WTO dispute settlement procedures)$B!"$H5,Dj$7$F$$$k!"-"#W#T#O6(Dj0cH?$NB8:_$rA0Ds$H$7$F$$$k#D#S#U#2#2!%#8>r!"#W#T#O6(Dj0cH?$N0lJ}E*G'Dj(B(unilateral determination)$B$r0lHLE*$K6X;_$7$F$$$k#D#S#U#2#3!%#2>r!J#a!K$NJ8L.$+$i$b!"-!$N2r(preserves the security and predictability of the WTO dispute settlement mechanism and the multilateral trade system it supports)$B!#(B

$B!!(determination)$B$H$O!"#W#T#O2CLA9q$,#W#T#O6(Dj$K0cH?$7$=$l$,#W#T#O$NKG0W4X78$K1F6A$rM?$($F$$$k$H7hDj$9$k$3$H(B(a decision that a WTO Member has violated the WTO Agreement and which bears consequences in WTO trade relations)$B$G$"$j!"#U#S#T#R$N8x<0@

$B!!%Q%M%k$O$^$?!"%Q%M%k!?>e5i0Q0w2qJs9p$Ny5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$N>5G'$r5a$a$k2CLA9q$,#W#T#OJ6Ah=hM}Z@UG$$rIi$o$J$/$F$O$J$i$J$$$H=R$Y$?!#(B

$B!!%Q%M%k$O!"r%Q%M%k$NJs9p$r$($kA0$K#D#S#B$K>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$N>5G'$r5a$a$?$3$H$O!"#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r0cH?$H$O$J$i$J$$$H7kO@$7$?!#-!#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r$K$h$l$P!"r$N5/Ap2aDx$h$j!"!V%*%j%8%J%k!&%Q%M%k$X$NIUBw$r(B$B4^$`(B(including recourse to the original panel)$B!W$H$$$&J88@$O!"#W#T#OJ6Ah=hM}$B4X$o$k(B(involving resort to the original panel wherever possible)$B!W$H$$$&J88@$+$iJQ99$5$l$?!"-##D#S#U#2#2!%#6>r$NCg:[y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$NDxEY$HL58z2=?/32$NDxEY$H$,F1Ey(B(equivalent)$B$+H]$+$r7hDj$9$k8"8B(B(authority)$B$rM-$7$F$$$k$,!"F1Ey$+H]$+$rH=CG$9$kA0Ds$H$7$Fe$NMx1W$rL58z2=?/32$7$F$$$k$+H]$+$bH=CG$7$J$/$F$O$J$i$:!"$7$?$,$C$F#D#S#U#2#2!%#6>r$NCg:[r$K5,Dj$5$l$kJ6Ah=hM}rrrr

$B!!$J$*%Q%M%k$O!"#2#1!%#5>r(original panel)$B$NJs9pDs=P4|8B$H>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_>5G'$r5a$a$k%?%$%_%s%0$H$N4X78(B(the relationship between one of the possible dispute settlement procedures that may be used, i.e. the recourse to the original panel which should issue its report within 90 days, and the timing of the right to request DSB authorization to suspend obligations and concessions)$B$K$D$$$F2CLA9q4V$KAh$$$,$"$j!"#D#S#U8+D>$7$NCf$G5DO@$5$l$F$$$k$H$$$&;v

$B!!0J>e$h$j%Q%M%k$O!"JF9q$,#E#C$Nr$K0cH?$7!"$7$?$,$C$F#D#S#U#2#3!%#1>r$K$b0cH?$7$F$$$k!"$H7kO@$7$?!J"(!K!#(B

 

$B"(J,@O

$B#D#S#U#2#1!%#5>r$K$h$l$P!"(original panel)$B$KIUBw$9$kI,MW$O$J$$$,!"2CLA9q$,0lJ}E*$KG'Dj$9$k$3$H$O6X;_$5$l$F$*$j!"$$$:$l$+$N#W#T#O?3M}5!4X!JCg:[?M$b4^$`!K$K;p$i$M$P$J$i$J$$!#$7$?$,$C$F!"#D#S#U#2#2!%#6>rCg:[?M$K$h$kH=CG$rBT$?$:$K#37n#3F|$NAr$K0cH?$7$?$H$$$&$3$H!#(B

 

$B#4!%$=$NB>(B

$B!!#E#C$O!"#37n#3F|$NAr$K0cH?$7$F$$$k$H$N?=N)$r9T$C$F$$$?$,!"%Q%M%k$O!"$9$G$KEv3:Ar$N0cH?!J%Q%M%k%9%H$N#1?M$O#G#A#T#T#1#1>r$N0cH?$rG'$a$F$$$k!K$r>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$KAjEv$9$k$H$7$FG'$a$F$$$k!#$^$?#G#A#T#T#8>r$K$D$$$F$O8!F$$7$J$$$b$N$H$9$k!"$H=R$Y$?!#(B

$B!!#E#C$N#D#S#U0cH?!JJ6Ah=hM}(counter-measures, reprisals or retaliatory measures)$B$O87$7$/5,@)$5$l!"#W#T#O!?#D#S#B$N@)EYE*OHAH$_(B(institutional framework of the WTO/DSB)$B$K$*$$$F$N$_#W#T#O6(Dj0cH?$rG'Dj$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!"-"(BUS-Section 301$B%Q%M%k7hDj$G$b;XE&$5$l$?$h$&$K!"#D#S#U$K5,Dj$5$l$k;~4V@)8B$OL\0B$G$7$+$J$$!#(B

 

 

*$B%Q%M%k$N(B$B7kO@5Z$S4+9p(B

$B#37n#3F|$NA

(a) $B#W#T#O0cH?Ar$K0cH?$7$F$$$k!#(B

(b) $B#E#C$NrJB$S$K#2#3!%#2>r!J#a!K!"#2#1!%#5>r$K0cH?$7$F$$$k!#(B

(c) $B#37n#3F|$NAe>h$;$d$=$l$KH<$&HqMQ$NA}2C$O!"#G#A#T#T#1!"#2!%#1>r!J#a!K!"#2!%#1>r!J#b!K$K0cH?$7$F$$$k!#(B

(d) $B>e5-(B(c)$B$N0cH?$O#D#S#U#3!%#7>r!"#2#2!%#6>r!"#2#3!%#2>r!J#c!K$K5,Dj$5$l$k>y5v$=$NB>$N5AL3Dd;_$KAjEv$7!"#D#S#B$N>5G'$J$/#D#S#U#2#2!%#6>r$NCg:[rJB$S$K#3!%#7>r!"#2#2!%#6>r!"#2#3!%#2>r!J#c!K$K0cH?$7$F$$$k!#(B

$B$J$*!"(B(c)$B$K4X$7$F!"%Q%M%j%9%H$N#1?M$O!"MBBw6b$N>e>h$;$O#G#A#T#T#1#1>r$K0cH?$7$F$$$k$H$$$&8+2r$G$"$C$?!#(B

 

$B#D#S#U#3!%#8>r$K$h$j!"0cH?$H$5$l$?JF9q$NAe$NMx1W$rL58z2=$^$?$O?/32$7$F$$$?$b$N$H0l1~(B(prima facie)$B7kO@$9$k!#(B

$B%Q%M%k$O!"#D#S#B$KBP$7!"JF9q$K@'@5A

 

 

©  2001  Yuka Fukunaga  All Rights Reserved